Tulane University
- A.b. Freedman School Of Business
- Administrator
- Affiliated Faculty
- Africa
- African Diaspora
- Africana Studies
- Afro Latinos
- Afro-caribbean Religion
- Afro-cuban
- Altman Program In International Studies & Business
- Amazon
- Ambassador Visit
- Center For Conflict And Cohesion Studies
- Center For Global Development
- Center For Global Education
- Center For Inter-american Policy And Research
- Central America
- Central American Policy
- Centro De Investigación Y Adiestramiento Político Administrativo
- Cepal
- Ceq
- Ceq Working Paper Series
- Chair In Economics
- Chavez
- Cipr
- Cipr And Iad Joint Seminar Series
- Cipr Post-doctoral Fellowship
- Ciprstaff
- Citizen Security
- City
- Colonialism
- Commitment To Equity
- Committee On World Food Security
- Communication
- Communications
- Community
- Cuban & Caribbean Studies
- Cuban-american Relations
- Cultural Rights
- Culture
- Culture And Community
- David Smilde
- Debt Crisis
- Declining Inequality
- Declining Inequality In Latin America
- Decompression
- Democrac
- Democracy
- Diplomat
- Disaster Relief
- Disaster Resilience Leadership Academy
- Discrimination
- Disposable Income
- Diversity
- Indigenous Latin American Languages
- Indigenous Rights
- Indirect Taxes
- Inequality
- Inflation
- Informal Urban Land Development
- Informal Urban Settlement
- Institutions
- Inter-american Court
- Inter-american Dialogue
- Inter-american Relations
- International Programs
- International Relations
- International Studies
- Intra-regional Trade
- Job Annoucement
- Job Announcement
- Job Opening
- Job Opportunity
- Journalism
- Judiciary
- K-12 Cuba Teacher Institute
- K-12 Teacher Workshop
- Kellogg Institute
- Music
- Natural Resources
- Neoliberal Policies
- Neoliberalism
- New Orleans
- New Orleans Center For The Gulf South
- Police Violence
- Policy
- Political Competition
- Political Economy
- Political Institutions
- Political Science
- Political Sociology
- Politicians
- Politics
- Politics Of Migration
- Popular Sector Incorporation
- Populism
- School Of Liberal Arts
- School Of Public Health & Tropical Medicine
- School Of Public Health And Tropical Medicine
- School Of Social Work
- Semester Abroad
- Sergio Bejar
- Speakers
- Staff
- State-society Relations
- Stone Center For Latin American Studies
- Student Funding
- Study Abroad
- (83) Politics
- (59) General Latin America
- (58) Venezuela
- (49) Political Science
- (47) Human Development
- (45) Commitment To Equity
- (24) Ceq Working Paper Series
- (21) Central America
- (21) Social Policy
- (19) Elections
- (17) Sociology
- (17) Costa Rica
- (17) Chile
- (16) Fiscal Policy
- (16) Political Economy
- (14) Latin American Legislative
- (14) Center For Inter-american Policy And Research
- (13) Future Of Cuba
- (9) Research
- (9) Stone Center For Latin American Studies
- (9) Ceq
- (8) Socialism
- (8) Cipr And Iad Joint Seminar Series
- (8) Anthropology
- (7) Fiscal Incidence
- (7) Core Faculty
- (7) International Relations
- (7) Environment
- (7) Literature
- (7) Income Redistribution
- (6) Spanish & Portuguese
- (6) Uruguay
- (6) Cuban & Caribbean Studies
- (6) Puerto Rico
- (6) Study Abroad
- (6) School Of Liberal Arts
- (6) New Wave
- (5) Declining Inequality
- (5) Cipr Post-doctoral Fellowship
- (5) Taxes
- (5) Southern Cone
- (5) Ciapa
- (5) Global Development
- (5) History
- (5) Policy
- (5) Social Justice
- (4) Center For Global Development
- (4) Redistribution
- (4) Undergraduate Students
- (4) Social Inclusion
- (4) Haiti
- (4) Dominican Republic
- (4) Populism
- (4) Guatemala
- (4) Ambassador Visit
- (4) Politics Of Migration
- (4) Hurricane Maria
- (4) Latin American Library
- (4) Imf
- (4) Econoimcs
- (4) China
- (3) Us-mexico Border
- (3) Tulane University
- (3) Education
- (3) Culture And Community
- (3) Neoliberalism
- (3) Declining Inequality In Latin America
- (3) A.b. Freedman School Of Business
- (3) Wacno
- (3) Globalization
- (3) Cooperative
- (3) Developing Democracies
- (3) Tulane
- (3) Cash Transfers
- (3) Voter Behavior
- (3) Extractivism
- (3) Labor
- (3) Environmental Studies
- (3) Violence
- (3) Graduate Conference
- (3) Inter-american Court
- (3) Coronavirus
- (2) Undergraduate Conference
- (2) Tucla
- (2) Social Equity
- (2) School Of Social Work
- (2) Social Inequalities
- (2) Migration
- (2) Tuscla
- (2) Reforms
- (2) Language
- (2) Comparative Politics
- (2) El Salvador
- (2) World Bank
- (2) Language And Culture
- (2) Public Policy
- (2) Police Violence
- (2) Ethno-racial Divide
- (2) Reading Project
- (2) Social Work
- (2) Award
- (2) Doctoral Program
- (2) Afro-caribbean Religion
- (2) Natural Resources
- (2) Oecd
- (2) Administrator
- (2) Job Announcement
- (2) Nora Lustig
- (2) Critical Race Theory
- (2) Public Opinion
- (2) Publications
- (2) Indigenous
- (2) Immigrants
- (2) Sergio Bejar
- (2) Mobility
- (2) Taxes And Transfers
- (2) Student Funding
- (2) Art
- (2) Nicaragua
- (2) Government Action
- (1) Central American Policy
- (1) K-12 Teacher Workshop
- (1) K-12 Cuba Teacher Institute
- (1) David Smilde
- (1) Graduate Students
- (1) Prison
- (1) Hurricane Katrina
- (1) Deportation
- (1) Study In Latin America
- (1) Government
- (1) Protests
- (1) Oil
- (1) Refugees
- (1) Social Mobilization
- (1) Social Justic
- (1) International Programs
- (1) Fundraising
- (1) Water Management
- (1) Forced Migration
- (1) Sustainability
- (1) Urban Ethnography
- (1) Lgbt
- (1) Kellogg Institute
- (1) Public Health
- (1) School Of Public Health And Tropical Medicine
- (1) Undergraduate
- (1) Diversity
- (1) Revolution
- (1) Tulaso
- (1) Greenleaf Fellow
- (1) New Orleans Center For The Gulf South
- (1) Latin Americanist Graduate Association
- (1) Lago
- (1) Lago Conference
- (1) Urbanism
- (1) Greenleaf Fellows
- (1) Slavery
- (1) International Studies
- (1) Outreach
- (1) Ethnography
- (1) Sustainable Development Goals
- (1) Catholic Church
- (1) Teacher Workshop; Outreach
- (1) French
- (1) Architecture
- (1) Indigenous Latin American Languages
- (1) Non-profit
- (1) Outrearch
- (1) Social Conflict
- (1) Audubon Zoo
- (1) Postcolonial Studies
- (1) Art History
- (1) African Diaspora
- (1) Middle American Research Institute
- (1) Job Opening
- (1) Center For Global Education
- (1) Relief
- (1) Disaster Resilience Leadership Academy
- (1) Trauma Institute
- (1) Cuban & Caribbean S
- (1) Mari
- (1) Authoritarianism
- (1) Gran Fiesta
- (1) Portuguese
- (1) Altman Program In International Studies & Business
- (1) Flas
- (1) New Orleans Film Festival
- (1) Democrac
- (1) Maduro
- (1) Elites
- (1) Africana Studies
- (1) Photography
- (1) Communications
- (1) Amazon
- (1) Identity
- (1) Graduate Student Conference
- (1) Community
- (1) Culture
- (1) City
- (1) Visiting Researcher
- (1) New York Times
- (1) Afro Latinos
- (1) Migrant
- (1) Migrant Workers
- (1) Peacekeeping
- (1) Paris
- (1) Hlpe Report
- (1) Venezuel
- (1) School Of Public Health & Tropical Medicine
- (1) Institutions
- (1) Rule Of Law
- (1) Benefit Incidence
- (1) Income
- (1) Hlpe
- (1) Urban Land Development
- (1) High Level Panel Of Experts
- (1) Nutrition
- (1) Committee On World Food Security
- (1) Food Security
- (1) Regional Agreements
- (1) Intra-regional Trade
- (1) Regionalism
- (1) Environmental Governance
- (1) Governance
- (1) Same Sex Marriage
- (1) Civil Society
- (1) Legislature
- (1) Transnational Activism
- (1) Effectiveness
- (1) Representation
- (1) State-society Relations
- (1) Informal Urban Land Development
- (1) Pension Reform
- (1) Forestry
- (1) Informal Urban Settlement
- (1) Legislatures
- (1) Transnational Law
- (1) Assembly Movements
- (1) Lasa 2010
- (1) Christian Science Monitor
- (1) Model Oas
- (1) Global Poverty
- (1) Global Economics
- (1) Roundtable
- (1) Meeting
- (1) Centro De Investigación Y Adiestramiento Político Administrativo
- (1) Political Competition
- (1) Celebracion Latina
- (1) Payson
- (1) Latino
- (1) Happiness
- (1) Debt Crisis
- (1) Film Series
- (1) Indigenous Rights
- (1) Ludovico Feoli
- (1) Fundación Vidanta
- (1) Buenos Aires
- (1) Teaching
- (1) Samuel P Huntington
- (1) Citizen Security
- (1) Prisons
- (1) Drug Trafficking
- (1) Anthony Pereira
- (1) Decompression
- (1) Inclusive Growth
- (1) Economic Forum
- (1) Fundación Rap
- (1) Transfers
- (1) Bolsa Familia
- (1) Mesoamerican
- (1) Poverty Reduction
- (1) Popular Sector Incorporation
- (1) Indirect Taxes
- (1) Semester Abroad
- (1) Fall
- (1) Music
- (1) Working Papers
- (1) Incidence Analysis
- (1) Repal
- (1) Public Sector
- (1) Inter-american Dialogue
- (1) Center For Conflict And Cohesion Studies
- (1) Social Dialogue
- (1) United Nations
- (1) Social Safeguards
- (1) Environmental Safguards
- (1) Private Sector
- (1) Spain
Carmelo Mesa Lago discusses Pension Reform in Argentina, Bolivia and Chile
April 9th, 2013
On March 19, 2013, Tulane University‘s Center for Inter-American Policy welcomed back former Greenleaf professor Carmelo Mesa-Lago for a lecture entitled ‘Re-reforms of Privatized Pensions in Latin America: Argentina, Bolivia, and Chile.‘ Mesa opened by explaining how eleven Latin American countries conducted structural reforms of their public pension systems during the 1980s and 1990s through either complete or partial privatizations. In the countries examined in his lecture, these reforms produced some positive changes but also several unsatisfactory outcomes that prompted Argentina, Bolivia, and Chile to implement substantial ‘re-reforms‘ in 2008 (Chile and Argentina) and in 2010 (Bolivia). Some of the negative outcomes of the initial reforms included the failure to successfully extend coverage for workers: coverage remained stagnant in Chile and Bolivia, while in Argentina it actually decreased by 45 percent. Other problems were the lack of gender equity and the failure of competition between private firms to effectively reduce administrative costs. The financial sustainability of the overall shift to privatized systems proved to be precarious. Transition periods were lengthy and costly, inducing large government debts. Capital returns in all three countries fell, the most drastic drop occurring in Chile, from 21 to 10 percent.
To remedy some of these negative outcomes Argentina, Bolivia, and Chile conducted ‘re-reforms‘, strengthening the role of the state in the pension system through diverse approaches. Chile maintained the privatized system but improved it; Argentina integrated the private system into the public system; and Bolivia nationalized its system. In terms of coverage, all three countries improved upon the previous system by extending coverage for the labor force and expanding coverage of non-contributory pensions. All three countries improved gender equity by compensating mothers for time spent raising children. In terms of financial sustainability, Mesa-Lago stressed that Chile had the greatest success in ensuring the long-term viability of its re-reforms, while the sustainability of the Argentine and Bolivian systems remain questionable. Capital returns have been increasing in Chile, while in Bolivia they have been falling, and in Argentina, they are negative. The deficit of Argentina‘s public fund is expected to increase five-fold over the next forty years, while in Bolivia, no long-term financial projections for the future of the state pensions fund have been established.
Mesa-Lago concluded by underscoring that the re-reforms have remedied many of the flaws of the initial privatization of pensions. He further emphasized that a one-size-fits-all approach with respect to pension reform is untenable because it fails to account for local specificities and internal dynamics of a given country. For example, while all three countries have expanded the role of the state in pensions, not all have pursued the outright closing of the private system. The Chilean case demonstrates how a privatized system can be maintained and substantially improved with state involvement. The case of Argentina demonstrates a successful example of integration of the private system into the public system, with the important caveat that other measures might have to be taken to ensure its long-term financial viability. Mesa-Lago added, as a final note, that it remains to be seen how these re-reforms will influence the complete or partially privatized pensions systems still in place in other Latin America countries.
-Hannagan Johnson

Copyright © 2021 Roger Thayer Stone Center For Latin American Studies All Rights Reserved.
Tulane University, 100 Jones Hall, New Orleans, LA 70118 (504) 865-5164 rtsclas@tulane.edu